Ice Cream
| Ben & Jerry's Ice Cream | 372 St. Armand's Circle #A | 388-5226 | |
| Big Olaf Creamery | 1267 Beneva Road | 365-7483 | |
| Big Olaf Creamery | 3350 Bahia Vista | 330-2028 | |
| Big Olaf Creamery | 5208 Ocean Boulevard | 349-9392 | |
| Cold Stone Creamery | 4248 South Tamiami Trail | 923-7300 | |
| Cold Stone Creamery | 1900 Main Street | 330-1880 | |
| Cone Zone | 5507 Fruitville Road | 343-9339 | |
| Dairy Queen | 3246 Clark Road | 925-9580 | |
| Edy's Grand Ice Cream | Sarasota Square Mall | 924-6623 | |
| Evie's Ice Cream Parlor | 4735 Bee Ridge Road | 377-2399 | |
| Ice Cream Racer II | 2301 Gulf Gate Drive | 922-3187 | |
| Jolly | 1296 North Palm Avenue | 906-1551 | |
| Jolly | 1970 Main Street | 955-4380 | |
| Kilwins Chocolates of St. Armand's | 312 John Ringling Boulevard | 388-3200 | |
| Sarasota Scoops | 5353 South Tamiami Trail | 921-1003 | |
| ScoopDaddy's - St. Armand's Circle | Blvd. of the Presidents | 388-1650 | |
| Smoothie King | 3800 South Tamiami Trail | 365-2244 | |
| Stricklands - Gulf Gate Mall | 6593 South Tamiami Trail | 330-329-5303 | |
| TCBY | 3800 South Tamiami Trail | 953-3241 | |
| Treat Street | 8398 South Tamiami Trail | 918-2474 |